Enver Solomon, deputy director of the Centre for Crime & Justice Studies, highlights the Conservatives latest policy proposals for reforming our prisons.
Think of Conservative policy on prisons and the image that comes to mind is of Michael Howard as Home Secretary rallying the troops at his party’s conference with the cry that ‘prison works’. That catch phrase has now been replaced with the new, softer sounding ‘prisons with a purpose’. It’s the title of the Conservatives latest policy proposals for reforming the nation’s jails. The report is the product of many weeks of consultation and research intended to come up with solutions to chronic overcrowding and stubbornly high reconviction rates.
A glance through the 113 page report and it would appear, at least from many of the headline messages, that David Cameron is shifting Conservative thinking away from the dogmatic ‘lock ‘em up’ agenda of the past to a more enlightened, even progressive prison reform agenda. The talk now is of a ‘rehabilitation revolution to break the cycle of crime’; women being held in ‘more local units’ and ‘alternative forms of secure, treatment based accommodation …for mentally ill and drugs offenders’. The aim is ‘the most fundamental shake-up of prisons for two centuries’ to bear down on ‘re-offending’ and, so the argument goes, reduce crime.
A more detailed reading of the report reveals that in reality, the Conservatives have not actually changed their minds and still hold dear to the view that ‘prison works’. They are trying to repackage their messages to be all about rehabilitation and tackling re-offending. Prison is still seen as the most important punishment for the majority of criminals. In fact the report argues that prison is being reserved for ‘serious, violent, persistent offenders’ and can be an effective crime reduction tool. It argues that … ‘a new approach should accept the role of prison in dealing with crime in an increasingly violent society.’
This is a naïve, simplistic and misinformed argument. The correlation between prison numbers and crime rates is extremely weak. The assessment by many criminologists is that economic trends, employment levels and relative income inequality, alongside technological developments and broader cultural and social changes, are the main influencers of crime trends. A recently released report from the Prime Minister’s Strategy Unit concluded that 80 per cent of the reduction in the official crime rate since 1997 was the result of economic, not criminal justice interventions. So to focus on prison rehabilitation as a policy lever for tackling crime and victimization is fundamentally flawed.
The report baldly states … ‘half of all crime is committed by previous offenders’. Yet there is no credible evidence to back this up. The reality is that crime is far more common than we think. Nearly all of us have broken the law and committed a crime at some stage in our lives, whether it be not paying tax, committing an insurance fraud or using illegal substances. Many men have assaulted or threatened their wives, partners, friends or acquaintances. What’s more, a third of men will have a criminal conviction by the age of 30.
Rather than being an effective means of reducing crime, the evidence suggests that prison is a crime generator as it causes huge social and economic harm to thousands of individuals, families and communities. The Social Exclusion Unit report on Reducing Re-offending by Ex-Prisoners, which the Conservatives quote from, vividly highlights the damage caused by imprisonment by breaking family relationships, leaving many prisoners jobless and homeless on release and without support for mental health and substance misuse needs. Prisons are by their very nature harsh, violent and disturbing places. They never have been and will never be therapeutic environments that heal and repair the multiple social problems which are common amongst the prison population. What’s more, the communities that have high imprisonment rates experience social breakdown that weakens the bonds that are protective factors against crime and disorder.
Solutions to reducing crime and promoting public safety lie outside the prison gates and beyond the criminal justice agencies. They are to be found in improved mental health services, drug treatment and alcohol services. Social development initiatives that address exclusion and disadvantage by providing effective support for communities will, in the long run, be far more effective than relying on punishment to stop crime. The Conservatives would be wise to address the need for proportionality in sentencing and move away from a misconceived utilitarian notion that rehabilitation can be used as a crime reduction tool. Of course prisons should seek to assist and support offenders, but they are ultimately places of punishment, not a social service, and so will never be an effective crime reduction tool.
Comments about this article
A Sorry Milestone
A Lump on the Forehead
Bribe For Foreign National Prisoners Triples To 3000
The Conservatives Plan To Reward Successful Prisons.
Does Life Now Mean Life?
How Journalism Works
Initial Categorisation of IPPs
"Well, how do you explain..."
Month by Month
Origin of a Sub-Species
Current page: Rehabilitation Revolution
We Act For Others...
This Way Up
August 2014 Headlines
Prisons Beyond Crisis
Money: prisoners do actually need it
Rehabilitation Revolution for sale
Understanding the balance between reality and drama
Out of their depth
Are they reall serious about stopping offending
To what extent does the life sentence meet its purpose
Month by Month August 2014
Cyberline over the wall
The shift from being inside to life on the outside
How can the ‘filtering’ of cautions and convictions for employment go further
Rethink Mental Illness
the PAROLE BOARD
My innocent brother
How safe a safety net
From over the wall
Technology in prisons: helping to keep families in touch
Sexual Offences Prevention Orders
Prison Law is Dead
Drugs testing in Jurby prison
So you think it is all over...
Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 Challenging surveillance evidence
New! Volume 5 of
is now available!
A collection of poems by prisoners of all backgrounds.
Availabe to buy from this site! Volume 1,2,3 and 4 are also still available and you can SAVE by purchasing bundles!
The Useful Services for Prisoners scheme from insidetime provides discounts, vouchers and other benefits from USP Group Members for Prisoners, their families and legal advisors. Click the image above to read more about it.
You can subscribe to insidetime Newspaper and get the paper each month delivered to your door!
Advertise your business or solicitors office to a highly defined target audience.
Inside Time has produced a number of books and publications you can purchase online.
All contact info for the Operations office and the Editorial Team.
Our site map page contains links to all pages on the insidetime site.
We have a number of external websites which you may be interested on our Links Page.
Everything you need to know about visiting people in prison; procedures, opening times, directions etc.
Comprehensive information about each prison regime; lock down times, facilities, healthcare etc.
*NEW* Detailed information about IRC - Immigration Removal Centres.
Various pages of information for help and support organisations and networks for those in custody as well as recently released. Also information for friends and family.
This grants and funding pdf document aims to meet the need of prisoners and ex-offenders for accurate, up to date information on the supplementary funding available to prisoners.
Information on rules & regulations used throughout the prison service.
The Glossary of Prison Related Terms explains what all the acronyms and terms stand for with prison related matters. Includes links to external sites to further explain things.
We have produced many Prison Related Fact Sheets inc. Legal Fact Sheets, Parole Fact Sheets and Other related information.
You can search our solicitor database for listings of solicitors in your area that provide the services you require.
You can search our barrister database for listings of barristers in your area that provide the services you require.
You can search our address database in many ways to retrieve contact information for all those elusive addresses you need in a hurry.
This document provides details of leading training providers who offer sound professional training.
Inside Information has produced a number of books and publications you can purchase online.
Our site map page contains links to all pages on the insideinformation site.
Use the Contact Us Feedback form to send us suggestions, plus our address and phone numbers.
insidejustice was launched in July 2010 to investigate alleged miscarriages of justice.
Full introduction is on the insidejustice homepage