Keith Rose looks at a risk instrument that is fundamentally flawed and cannot be used as a measure of what an individual may do in the future.
Is your budgie a psychopath? How would you tell? What is a psychopath? The Oxford English Dictionary defines ‘psychopathy’ as follows; psychopathic personality; an antisocial personality characterized by the failure to develop any sense of moral responsibility and the capability of performing violent or antisocial acts.
How do you diagnose a psychopathic budgie? Qualified, well trained psychiatrists state: 'conduct a series of risk assessments over a reasonable period of time to enable suitable treatment to be decided on and then carried out'. Prison Service psychologists' state: 'ask questions around 20 main headings … and psychopathic budgies are untreatable anyhow'.
The psychologists 'magic questions' come from the Hare ‘Psychopathy Check List’ (revised). The Hare PCL-r is centred on questions under 20 headings which determine if an individual can be classed as a psychopath. Each heading scores up to 2 points, giving a maximum score of 40. Any score above 28 in Texas reputedly incurs the death penalty in murder cases. It is frequently used in the UK prison service just before a prisoner or long term mental patient is about to be released. The bulk of the items scored are historic and cannot change, so use of this test as a predictor of future behaviour automatically rules out the possibility of change; a 20 year-old subjected to the Hare PCL-r would carry an unchanging score for the rest of their lives.
Professor Robert Hare, the author of the Hare PCL-r, highlights the fundamental flaw which leads to his test being widely misapplied, if not actually abused, as follows: "The use of the PCL-r in the criminal justice system ... sometimes leads to the conclusion that it is primarily a risk instrument rather than what it really is, a measure of a psychological construct". (Source: page 87, Technical manual PCL-r Ed. July 2005).
Legal authorities like parole boards obviously crave reliable indicators that a person under scrutiny presents a low risk of re-offending. What Professor Hare points out so succinctly is that use of the Hare PCL-r as a risk instrument is flawed; it cannot show intent; it cannot be used for risk assessment, a measure of what an individual may do in the future.
Nevertheless, that is exactly the use it is being put to by prison service psychologists, pure cod-psychology. Professor Hare sounds a further note of caution by stating that: "Whilst psychopathy is a clinical construct ... the factors responsible for psychopathy are not well understood" (Source: page 7, Technical manual PCL-r 2. Ed. July 2005). In other words, reliance on the PCL-r should not be considered absolute.
The PCL-r is also routinely used as a tool to identify prisoners said to be suffering from a ‘Dangerous, Severe, Personality Disorder’ suitable for admission to a DSPD unit. Pre-2002, if one scored over 30 one was labelled as 'psychopathic' suffering from DSPD. Post-2002, the score was lowered to 25. Curiously, the Home Office have consistently denied that the PCL-r result is a diagnostic tool, perhaps due to the fact that the Hare PCL-r tests are invariably conducted by trainee psychologists, usually unqualified and inexperienced, and prone to errors and mistakes.
So appalled by the use, abuse and misuse of the PCL-r in prisons was Dr Bob Johnson, former Head of Therapy at Ashworth Hospital and Consultant Psychiatrist to the Home Office, that he created an analysis of the medical and legal flaws in the PCL-r. This is available as a free download at 'www-TruthTrustConsent.com'. Moreover, anybody can purchase the full Hare PCL-r complete with question book, technical manuals and analysis books from 'Multi Health Systems' at 'www-mhs.com' from around £140.
The Hare PCL-r main headings:
Conceivably the most disturbing fact about the Hare PCL-r is the reliance on the opinion of the questioner, and the simple fact that no human can ever achieve a zero score.
Returning to the opening question: is your budgie a psychopath? Probably not, as it is a social bird usually living in a flock and not prone to random acts of violence. Cats, on the other hand, come close to the maximum score of 40, failing only on item 19, revocation of conditional release.
Other notable maximums of the Hare PCL-r include: George W Bush (for obvious reasons), Tony Blair (sectioned, not retired), Gordon Brown (vetoed prisoners’ pay rise), Michael Howard (something of the night), David Blunkett (obviously), anybody from Yorkshire (centuries of inbreeding) and the entire armed forces of the USA (collateral damage).
Hare PCL-r 2nd Ed. July 2005; Dr Bob Johnson MA, PhD, MBCS, DPM, MRCS, MRCPsych, MRCGP, Diploma in Psychotherapy, Neurology & Psychiatry (Psychiatric Institute of New York), Former Head of Therapy, Ashworth Hospital, Former Home Office Consultant Psychiatrist, The James Naylor Foundation 'Unsafe at Any Dose' 'Emotional Health' (ISBNs 0-95519851-8 & 0-9551985-0-X respectively); Panorama BBC 1, 3rd March 1997
Comments about this article
There are no comments, be the first to leave one!
Independent review of prison work accuses Prison Service of incompetence.
A Pawned Soul - A Tale of Love, Loyalty & Devotion
Ho! Ho! Ho! - A modern Christmas Tale
Bob Woffinden writes …
A decade of change
Looking back on 2008 … and beyond
Factories of repression
If it was left to me
Current page: Is your budgie a psychopath?
Restraint & Receivers … your money or theirs?
Short tariff IPP sentences
Zimmer Frame Society
Month by Month
Lags and Wags - Xmas Special
Scottish children in adult jails.
Babies in prison: could reach 200 this year
Votes for prisoners: time for action not words.
March 2014 Headlines
The price of injustice
I used art to get out of the sticky stuff
Homicides in prison
The Parole Board takes action to ensure fair and timely reviews
Parole in the brave new world
The problem with memory
You will be believed’ is the Police and CPS mantra for claims of sex offences
Inhuman treatment for sex offenders: Scotland goes back to the future
The right to rights
Month by Month - March 2014
Criminal Justice and Courts Bill
Thinking about legal action
Jobs after jail
The price of injustice
Bob Woffinden writes March 2014
From over the wall
The Kids are alright
Appealing against conviction
Shaun Kellett at the Smith Partnership wants to help you
Conspiracy to Defraud – what’s the silver bullet
Will your voice now be heard
The future of the Parole Board and IPP...a downward slope
Mothers Day Messages
New! Volume 5 of
is now available!
A collection of poems by prisoners of all backgrounds.
Availabe to buy from this site! Volume 1,2,3 and 4 are also still available and you can SAVE by purchasing bundles!
The Useful Services for Prisoners scheme from insidetime provides discounts, vouchers and other benefits from USP Group Members for Prisoners, their families and legal advisors. Click the image above to read more about it.
You can subscribe to insidetime Newspaper and get the paper each month delivered to your door!
Advertise your business or solicitors office to a highly defined target audience.
Inside Time has produced a number of books and publications you can purchase online.
All contact info for the Operations office and the Editorial Team.
Our site map page contains links to all pages on the insidetime site.
We have a number of external websites which you may be interested on our Links Page.
Everything you need to know about visiting people in prison; procedures, opening times, directions etc.
Comprehensive information about each prison regime; lock down times, facilities, healthcare etc.
*NEW* Detailed information about IRC - Immigration Removal Centres.
Various pages of information for help and support organisations and networks for those in custody as well as recently released. Also information for friends and family.
This grants and funding pdf document aims to meet the need of prisoners and ex-offenders for accurate, up to date information on the supplementary funding available to prisoners.
Information on rules & regulations used throughout the prison service.
The Glossary of Prison Related Terms explains what all the acronyms and terms stand for with prison related matters. Includes links to external sites to further explain things.
We have produced many Prison Related Fact Sheets inc. Legal Fact Sheets, Parole Fact Sheets and Other related information.
You can search our solicitor database for listings of solicitors in your area that provide the services you require.
You can search our barrister database for listings of barristers in your area that provide the services you require.
You can search our address database in many ways to retrieve contact information for all those elusive addresses you need in a hurry.
This document provides details of leading training providers who offer sound professional training.
Inside Information has produced a number of books and publications you can purchase online.
Our site map page contains links to all pages on the insideinformation site.
Use the Contact Us Feedback form to send us suggestions, plus our address and phone numbers.
insidejustice was launched in July 2010 to investigate alleged miscarriages of justice.
Full introduction is on the insidejustice homepage